Several years ago Rosa Park’s papers made it to the Library of Congress. Among them was her recipe for “Featherlite Peanut Butter Pancakes.” I had two thoughts when I saw this: peanut butter and “featherlite” don’t seem to go together and how could I make them into gluten-free peanut butter pancakes?
Well the conversion to make these pancakes gluten-free was a breeze and yes, they are featherlite thanks to 2 TABLEspoons of baking powder. I know that sounds like way too much baking powder for a recipe with just one cup of flour. But it works and you don’t taste the baking powder at all.
These pancakes are easily made dairy-free with the use of a milk substitute. Parks’ recipe calls for 2 Tbsps. sugar but I used natural unsweetened peanut butter so I added an extra 2 tsps. sugar.
I’m sure that almond butter would be a great substitute for the peanut butter or even sun butter if you avoid all nuts. Top these gluten-free pancakes with your favorite jam and you have the perfect PBJ combo.
More Gluten-Free Breakfast Recipes
Gluten-Free Flour Blends
I have used several different gluten-free flour blends for these gluten-free peanut butter pancakes and they all worked well. My custom blend of sorghum, millet and brown rice flours with some starches is my favorite. See the notes in the recipe for a super simple DIY gluten-free flour blend or my blog post on gluten-free flours.
If you prefer a store bought blend, I recommend either King Arthur Flour All Purpose Gluten-Free Flour or King Arthur Measure for Measure Flour. Whichever flour mix you use, if yours contains xanthan gum, guar gum or inulin (binders) omit the xanthan gum in the recipe.
The First Pancake
The first pancake on the pan almost always is a throw away. Why? Usually because the pan is not the right temperature. To avoid a bad first pancake, it is best to first heat the pan it over medium heat. Then, lightly grease the cooking surface with oil or butter, wiping away the excess with a paper towel. If you leave too much butter or oil the pancakes won’t have that nice even golden brown on top. Try making a test pancake with a small spoonful of batter to see if the pan is the right temperature.